The boxed off area is what "alerted" me, in, oh, about five seconds, that something was wrong with the pic. Of couse, I use Photoshop practically every day at work.
Looking at the picture again, the top of the adjacent smoke cloud also looks Clonebrushed. Like the photo was originally shorter or something so they just made a horizontal block first, then went upward. It has the same telltale patches of strangely-coloured pixels and pattern repetition. Anyone who has ever used Photoshop for any purpose should recognise at least some of the editing on sight; fuck, I use it for art rather than photo manipulation and it was still immediately obvious. I noticed the stuff outside your red box before the red box itself. (As an artist, you learn to spot Dodge-Burn shading/cheating very quickly. It is the milk of the lazy.) The only way I can imagine that this got through is that the person doing photo approvals must have gotten a huge block of similar photos all at once and just got into the rote button-pushing habit after two hundred burning Mideasts too many. An excellent reminder of the need to take breaks.
Oh yeah... The other cloud of smoke is bad too, but I first noticed the one on the left. I do consider it the worst example in the photo. I mean, the other cloud of smoke is bad too, but it's not quite as bad. At least to me.
no subject
no subject
no subject