More on alternate history
Sep. 1st, 2009 12:56 amHoly balls. I've been reading up on World War I, and I think I know why I've never seen anyone do a alternate history of it.
It would be fucking difficult to do well.
I mean, okay, let's face it... there's a lot of alt-history about WWII. Most of it is "What if the Nazis had won?", although Harry Turtledove takes a somewhat different route and has aliens invade during the war. And, while it's not necessarily much easier to write alt-history of WWII (or for that matter, any fiction), it's easier to determine who the antagonists are. (Here's a hint. They're Nazis.)
But World War I? It saw the end of the German, the Austro-Hungarian, the Ottoman and the Russian Empires. Hell, the causes of WWII can be traced to the end of WWI. Not to mention the rise of Communism, the partitioning of the Middle East (although that had started before the Ottoman Empire jumped into WWI), and a number of other things that people are still dealing with to this day.
I mean, okay, let's say, for shits and giggles, that the Triple Alliance managed to not lose. Not that necessarily won, but that they managed to bring it to a draw. You wouldn't have the rise to power of Adolf Hitler if the Hollenzollerns hadn't been forced to abdicate. You wouldn't necessarily have all the Middle Eastern countries set up the way they are if the Ottoman Empire hadn't been cut up into chunks.
Heck, with a strong Germany and Austro-Hungary after WWI, you probably wouldn't see the same expansion of Communism out of Russia.
I really need to do more research into this.
It would be fucking difficult to do well.
I mean, okay, let's face it... there's a lot of alt-history about WWII. Most of it is "What if the Nazis had won?", although Harry Turtledove takes a somewhat different route and has aliens invade during the war. And, while it's not necessarily much easier to write alt-history of WWII (or for that matter, any fiction), it's easier to determine who the antagonists are. (Here's a hint. They're Nazis.)
But World War I? It saw the end of the German, the Austro-Hungarian, the Ottoman and the Russian Empires. Hell, the causes of WWII can be traced to the end of WWI. Not to mention the rise of Communism, the partitioning of the Middle East (although that had started before the Ottoman Empire jumped into WWI), and a number of other things that people are still dealing with to this day.
I mean, okay, let's say, for shits and giggles, that the Triple Alliance managed to not lose. Not that necessarily won, but that they managed to bring it to a draw. You wouldn't have the rise to power of Adolf Hitler if the Hollenzollerns hadn't been forced to abdicate. You wouldn't necessarily have all the Middle Eastern countries set up the way they are if the Ottoman Empire hadn't been cut up into chunks.
Heck, with a strong Germany and Austro-Hungary after WWI, you probably wouldn't see the same expansion of Communism out of Russia.
I really need to do more research into this.